Aldila RIP Phenom Golf Shaft Review

ALDILA RIP PHENOM

By Russ Ryden, A Golf Digest America’s 100 Best Clubfitter
Fit2Score, Dallas Fort Worth, Texas

Aldila_Phenom

The Aldila Phenom is a smoother version of the RIP Alpha. Like the RIP Alpha, the light version 50 gram model has a different profile than the 70 gram version. The butt stiffness of the 70 gram version is much stiffer that the 50 gram model. The torque ranges from 6.8 in the 50R to 4.1 in the 50g TX model. While that R flex number may seem high, the raw 46″ shaft actually weighs 47.6 grams and will build out at around 45 grams. One must be careful when looking at shaft labels on light weight shafts. The labels often understate the actual weights of the shafts. That is not the case with the Aldila Phenom. The RIP Phenom 70S torque is 3.4 and the Tour X is 2.9. The radial profiles are very good, the shaft can be installed in any orientation.

Aldila_Phenom_EiGj
The balance point of the Aldila RIP Phenom moves toward the butt as the weight increases.  The 50g R is at 23″ and the 70g Tour X is at 25″.  This appears to be intentional as most other shafts from Aldila hold a consistent balance through weights and models.  This shafts is a mid-low launch design.  The Tour X designation on this shaft is new for Aldila.  That shaft is designed as the designation states, as a tour quality shaft.  The butt torque is 2.9, tip torque 2.1.  The EI profile is smoother, and by design, the butt is stiff.  The profile of the 70 Tour X is not that far from a Mitsubishi ‘ahina with half degree higher torque.  That small amount of torque difference will remove the sense of stiffness from this low launch design.

Aldila RIP Golf Shaft Review

ALDILA RIP

By Russ Ryden, A Golf Digest America’s 100 Best Clubfitter
Fit2Score, Dallas Fort Worth, Texas

The Aldila RIP was introduced to the golf consumer in 2010. RIP stands for reverse interlaminar placement.  Meaning, some of the bias plies that create torque were moved from the placement near the mandral to the outside of the shaft walls. The longitudinal plies, that create stiffness were sandwiched between the bias plies.  This reconfiguration increased torque and hoop strength, creating a more stable shaft with a different feel.

The profile is a change from the Aldila NV, like many of today’s designs, it shows multiple hinge points. It is one of the few shafts that lose stiffness toward the tip will holding low torque. The 70g version is a good shaft for creating mid to high launch fairways.

With the introduction of the RIP line of shafts, Aldila began putting torque numbers on the label.  With the 60 gram versions we found the torque numbers a little higher than our system, while the 70 gram versions we quite similar to our measurements.  The radial profiles are very good, the shafts can be installed in any orientation.

The RIP comes in three versions.  A Greek letter on the shaft indicates the version. The color of the eyes in the logo changes on each version.

Aldila RIP Alpha

Aldila_RIP_Alpha
The RIP Alpha, has red eyes. The Aldila RIP profiles are different in the 60g and the 70g models as shown. The radial profiles are very good, the shaft can be installed in any orientation. As you can see in the EI profiles, the shaft looses stiffness toward the tip.  With shafts of this type, tipping will increase stiffness without changing the design intent of the shaft.  When we see stiffness increases toward the tip, tipping can cut away some of the stiffest portion of the tip.  That is not the case with the Aldila RIP design.  We find the RIP to be mid launching shafts.

Aldila_RIP_Alpha_EiGj

 

Aldila RIP Beta

Aldila_RIP_BetaWhite

This image shows the white version of the Aldila RIP.  All of the Aldila RIP models are available in either white or black.  In this photo, you can clearly see the Greek letter and the torque number in between the weight and stiffness.  The  Aldila RIP Beta, green eyes, has the same shaft geometry as the RIP Alpha from Butt to Mid. The tip is softer, yielding a higher launch and spin. In the heavier models, the Aldila RIP Beta is a great high launch low torque fairway shaft. The torque ranges from 4.9 in the 60R to 2.7 in the 70X Aldila RIP Beta, slightly higher than the Alpha.  The profile does not change in the heavier models.Aldila_RIP_Beta_EiGj

 

Aldila RIP Gamma

Aldila_RIP_Gamma

The Aldila RIP Gamma, yellow eyes, is a close match to the RIP Alpha. It is counterweighted. The balance point is about an inch and a half closer to the butt. This allows those that rely on swing weight to create a driver with a heavier head and still have a D2 swing weight. For those clubmakers that have moved on to MOI balancing this seems a bit archaic. It can be seen as a reminder of the weakness of the swing weight system. If you are looking for a counterweighted RIP Alpha, the RIP Gamma is just that. Or, you can do what Jack Nicklaus is reported to have done, and put a little lead tape under your grips. Many golf professionals have not been exposed to MOI balanced clubs and rely on a 90 year old scale design for club balance. Tradition runs strong in golf and the RIP Gamma caters to that tradition.

 

Aldila RIP Sigma

Aldila RIP Sigma is an OEM design. The samples tested were designed for Tour Exotic Fairways. The premium after market Adila RIP Alpha 70g X flex has a 2.6 torque while the ‘designed for’ version is 4.2. Based on limited samples the design is a hybrid of the Alpha and Beta. This is one more example of product compromises made to achieve price points that the golf consumer considers competitive and reasonable. In defense of the club companies, they simply deliver what the consumer is willing to pay for.  Branded shafts in branded clubs, often sold for less than the price of the premium aftermarket shaft that gets played on tour, do not have the same manufacturing specs or tolerances as the tour quality shaft.

Aldila NV and Aldila RIP NV Golf Shaft Review

ALDILA NV & ALDILA RIP NV

By Russ Ryden, A Golf Digest America’s 100 Best Clubfitter
Fit2Score, Dallas Fort Worth, Texas

Aldila NVAldila_NV

The Aldila NV design has been with us for a long time. It is hard to miss that shiny green shaft. But lately, I have not seen many of them in golfers bags. It is a classic design and many, many near matches can be found in other shaft companies product lines.The torque ranges from 3.7 in the 60R to 3.2 in the 70X shafts. The Aldila NV profiles are consistent from weight to weight and flex to flex. I have only checked a few radial profiles, by they were 99.5%, indicating the shaft can be installed in any orientation.
Aldila_NV_EiGj

Aldila RIP NV

Aldila_RIP_NV
What do you do with a dated good design. Aldila created a second generation version rather than walking away from the brand name. The RIP NV applies the new interlay design to the classic NV design. The muted color scheme is more appealing to my conservative eye.
The torque ranges from 4.3 in the 60R to 3.2 the 65 Tour X shaft. Like all shafts in the RIP line, the torque value is printed on the shaft.  These numbers are very close to our measuring standard and are a good guide to the overall torque of the shaft.  The Aldila RIP NV profiles are consistent from weight to weight and flex to flex. The radial profiles are very good, the shaft can be installed in any orientation.

What we see different in the RIP NV is a reversal of the mid stiffness.  Where one might refer to the original NV as mid soft, the RIP NV is viewed as mid stiff.  This is a trend we see in may shaft designs over the past few years.  RIP stands for reverse interlaminar placement.  Aldila moved some of the bias plies of the shaft from the center, near the mandrel toward the outside of the shaft.  This sandwiched the longitudinal plies in the center of the shaft walls.

Aldila_RIP_NV_EiGj

Aldila VooDoo Golf Shaft Review

ALDILA VOODOO

By Russ Ryden, A Golf Digest America’s 100 Best Clubfitter
Fit2Score, Dallas Fort Worth, Texas

Aldila_VooDoo
The VooDoo, introduced in 2007 was the first shaft from Aldila to feature S-Core Technology. It has a corkscrew rib on the inside of the shaft. It has a simple Flexural Signature, consistently softer down the shaft to 18” where it evenly gains stiffness toward the tip. The torque ranges from 4.5 in the 60R to 3.2 in the 70X shafts. The Aldila Voodoo profiles are consistent from weight to weight and flex to flex. The radial profiles are very good, the shaft can be installed in any orientation.
Aldila_VooDoo_EiGj

Mitsubishi Fubuki Golf Shaft Review

MITSUBISHI FUBUKI DRIVER AND FAIRWAY SHAFTS

By Russ Ryden, A Golf Digest America’s 100 Best Clubfitter
Fit2Score, Dallas Fort Worth, Texas

FubukiTour

It was hard to miss noticing the Fubuki Tour on Television on Sunday afternoon. The distinctive white color is became so common it got copied by other brands. It is a variation of the White Board profile with a stiffer tip but softer mid. The second generation white board, the Diamana ‘ahina brought in an even stiffer tip. The Fubuki Tour shaft is now often used by tour players in fairways. The profile is similiar to the Diamana ‘ahina, with a softer, higher launching tip. The Fubuki Tour will be phased out in 2014. The profile of the Fubuki K offers the same feel and loading characteristics with a slightly stiffer tip.

The softer tip of the The Fubuki Tour introduced a slightly higher launch to the popular White Board design. It is a perfect pairing for a player looking for a slightly higher launching fairway, while still retaining the feel and control of a mid stiff shaft. Like all Mitsubishi Rayon golf shafts, the profiles of the Fubuki Tour are consistent from weight to weight and flex to flex. The butt torque ranges from 4.1 in the 50R to 2.6 in the 80X.  The tip torque of the Fubuki Tour 70 and 80 x is 2.0, a great number for a fairway shaft.

 

Mitsubishi Fubuki Alpha

FubukiAlpha

A 2010 profile from Mitsubishi called “Acceleration Technology”. It is promoted as delivering high launch and low spin. I have found it to be a mid to low mid launching golf shaft design. I refer to this as a Kai’li on steroids. The profile is a blend of the ‘ahina and Kai’li designs.

It is available in 55 – 75 grams. Among the sub 60 gram shafts it is unique. A tour profile in a light weight shaft. The butt is not as stiff as the Kai’li and the mid is not as soft. The tip is tight in both longitudinal and radial directions. The white driver shaft you saw on TV on weekends, this was it until the Fubuki K came along. The overall torque of the Fubuki Alpha ranges from 4.1 in the 50R to 2.5 in the 80X. The Fubuki Alpha profiles are consistent from weight to weight and flex to flex. The radial profiles are excellent; the shaft can be used in any orientation. The Fubuki Alpha 65 gram is the stock shaft in the 2012 Adams Fast 12 LS driver. That makes the Adams Fast 12 LS driver a unique value proposition.

 Mitsubishi Fubuki K

FubukiK

The Fubuki K was introduced in late 2011. The MDT shaft material is enhanced with a metallic “lace” in the butt section. This creates a stable butt without having to add a lot of carbon fiber. The profile called “Acceleration Technology” by Mitsubishi is similar to the original Fubuki Tour with a slightly firmer butt and tip.

The Fubuki K, unlike the Fubuki Alpha profile, is very similar to the ‘ahina with a higher tip to butt ratio resulting is a higher launch. It is a soft tip ‘ahina. The torque ranges from 4.1 in the 50R to 2.5 in the 80X shafts. The tip torque of this shaft is among the lowest I have measured. The Fubuki K profiles are consistent from weight to weight and flex to flex. The radial profiles are excellent; this shaft can be used in any orientation. Yes, the tour version 80X is in my driver fitting system for you gorillas out there. Like the original Fubuki Tour, it is a perfect compliment to the ‘ahina as a higher launching, higher spinning fairway shaft.

Fubuki EiGj
A look at the EI profiles of the Mitsubishi Fubuki golf shafts shows the similarity between the original Tour and the third generation K versions.  The Alpha is a different design and launches lower.

Mitsubishi Fubuki Ax Fairway

Fubuki_FW_AX

The Fubuki Ax is a fairway shaft. The raw shaft is several inches shorter than a driver shaft. The weights range from 50 to 85 grams. It is a close match to the Diamana Blue Board. The profiles and torques are much the same. Its a mid high launching shaft. The Fubuki Ax fairway is a mid price shaft, making for economical fairway clubs with a high performance shaft. The comparison with the Fubuki Alpha is shown below. A stiffer butt design follows the preference of many tour players in their fairways. The overall torque of the Fubuki Ax Fairway ranges from 4.3 in the 50R to 3.1 in the 80X. Tip torques on the heavier, stiffer versions are around 2.5. The Fubuki Ax profiles are consistent from weight to weight and flex to flex. The radial profiles are good; the shaft can be used in any orientation. The 65 gram version of the shaft is standard in the Adams 2012 Super XTD fairway.
Fubuki Fairway

As with all Mitsubishi shafts, you should see a club fitter to select the best fit of profile, weight and stiffness to your swing.